Hanging notes, and a possible narrowing down of the problem

So I’ve been working with support ever since August, on and off, to solve this issue. I think I’ve boiled it down to steps that are reproducible.

It seems midi off events on notes that are very short aren’t processed properly by the Muse, and result in hanging notes. It should be noted that this does not occur on any of my other hardware synthesizers. Not even my Behringers!

If those of you who also have stuck or hanging notes want to try to reproduce using my instructions and sample project, I’d be very interested and grateful to hear if you experience the same results.

Welp, I did have some attachments on this post. Looks like there was an error: “Sorry, the board attachment quota has been reached.” @Mods - can we please allow attachments again?

Hi. New to this Forum. Love my Muse but I have the same problem, did you ever resolve this issue?

Seems that the processing speed of the MIDI stack within the Muse is too slow. I don’t know the internals of the Muse software, but I know from serial communication processing in general that normally a ringbuffer is used to load an incoming (MIDI-)byte interrupt driven that no byte is lost.

When I was trouble shooting terminal software for customers in the past I faced that problem when the ring buffer was configured too small in RAM.

If the effect occurs with only one NOTE ON immediately followed by the corresponding NOTE OFF no overload happens, but the RXD / UART receiving interrupt routine is implemented ineficiently.

Wondering if you ever got this issue sorted? I just picked up a Muse and updated the Firmware but after connecting to Ableton via USB I started noticing stuck notes. I have owned various analogs since the 80’s including Oberheim, Sequentia,l Roland and others and if I remember correctly some of my synths had an issue with sticking notes over midi. On my Matrix 6R the setting to prevent this is called Active Sense. Anyway I haven’t tried midi other than over USB so I’m hoping it doesn’t happen with the midi ports.

I know two reasons why MIDI notes hang: Problems with ACTIVE SENSE and / or missing NOTE OFF after a NOTE ON (connection problem, timing problem, software / MIDI stack problem)

I highly recommend to trace the MIDI I/O with a MIDI monitor. This helps to identify the reason.

1 Like

If these problems arise using midi via USB, I would HIGHLY recommend trying out different USB cables. I had horrible midi performance, but then tried a cable with these ferrite cores on both ends, and problems were gone.

Having used quite a few usb-midi devices, I would say that Muse is definitely picky about the cable you use.

1 Like