... And now for something completely different

I found a wonderful interview with Hariprasad Chaurasia, player of the Indian Bansuri flute. I am posting this here because the flute, like the Moog synthesizer, is also a monophonic instrument and because the interview shows to what lengths a musician can go to achieve his goal. His music is highly recommended as an inspiration for our own playing technique, and the interview serves as food for thought while pondering our arguments along the lines of old/new school and vintage/analog etc.

Excerpt where he describes his search for a guru, a teacher.

"Anna Purna Devi played the surbahar and when I went to her for the first time, she threw me out. As it is, filmi musicians have a flaky reputation, on top of that I played the flute, and not surbahar, her forte and thirdly she wondered why was I coming to her and not going to Raviji. The second time she threatened to call the police, but I persisted, and finally after three years of persistently dogging her, she finally relented. She asked me to play something and when I did, she said, that if I had to learn from her, I had to start from scratch.

To show her I was serious. I decided to switch hands. I used to play with my right-hand, I switched to the left and believe me it is sheer torture. It’s like if I tell you that instead of walking straight, walk backwards for the rest of your life without looking back. I used to cry in sheer agony."

http://www.littleindia.com/march2005/PrayingwiththeFlute.htm

Source:
http://www.musicalnirvana.com/hindustani/hariprasad_chaurasia.html

Are there any polyphonic wind instruments (excluding wind controllers)?

The harmonica can play chords and single notes.
An accordion is half wind/half keyboard instrument, as is the harmonium. The chuch organ works with wind as well.
Some flute players can play two flutes at a time.
Bagpipes can play a drone note and a melody note.

Plus there’s always overdubbing and sampling.

The melodica!

Yeah, cultured music isn’t for everybody. Maybe a little respect would be okay.

I don’t think he meant to disrespect, only that the title of your thread is a Monty Python movie and that image is from a Monty Python skit.

Cultured music? What’s that? :smiley:

i have a harmonium, it’s awsome!!

how about that thing, it’s like a Y shaped pipe, one deviation has the holes to change pitch and the other is for drone sounds. you know the one that pan plays, but not the pan pipes.

I used to play with flutists alot when i was in universtiy and some really good flutists can actually do double stops but it is limited I think it has something to do with overblowing harmonics or something. this is more in the realm of special effects because each note is only allowed i think one or two additional pitces. i don’t think it’s possible to do like contrary movement scales or anything like that.