Page 3 of 3
Posted: Sat May 02, 2009 12:17 pm
by Just Me
This is a controller I'd like to get my hands on. I saw one once years ago and should have bought it.
http://www.oldtech.com/synth/OctCatstick.html
Posted: Mon May 04, 2009 3:27 pm
by Voltor07
That's an interesting thing there, Just Me. I'd like one of those, as well I think. It looks like a totally analog MP-201.

Posted: Tue May 05, 2009 9:23 pm
by Lux_Seeker
Voltor07 wrote:That's an interesting thing there, Just Me. I'd like one of those, as well I think. It looks like a totally analog MP-201.

This is the ultimate controller in my book:
http://www.buchla.com/series200e.html
I would love to see Moog Music come up with a lower cost version of this.
I will eventually buy a modular but I am not sure how well this would interface with one, especially Euro rack which is probably the format I will have.
Posted: Tue May 05, 2009 9:44 pm
by Voltor07
Lux_Seeker wrote:
This is the ultimate controller in my book:
http://www.buchla.com/series200e.html
I would love to see Moog Music come up with a lower cost version of this.
I will eventually buy a modular but I am not sure how well this would interface with one, especially Euro rack which is probably the format I will have.
Moog won't build one. Know why? Because Buchla has been building those for almost as long as Bob Moog's name has been famous! That's Don Buchla's baby. Now, the Moog PianoBar was made by Buchla and Associates but sold through Moog. Perhaps a partnership like that would be a thought? That doesn't help with the cost, and the logistics of such a partnership would be nightmarish. I personally like the Lightning III, but would never expect Moog to either make or sell them.

Posted: Tue May 05, 2009 11:20 pm
by matt the fiddler
Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 12:52 am
by Voltor07
LOL, Matt...we've mentioned those things numerous times, and have always come to the conclusion that they are WAY too expensive.

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 6:36 am
by Lux_Seeker
I do understand the relationship of Moog and Buchla and it's true, a very expensive product. But I find myself wondering is something like this can't be made less expensive. Certainly the Korg Chaos pad has enjoyed great sucess and is also very much affordable.
There is also the Harkin Continuum but to me, not nearly as innovative as the Thunder design. To me, the continuum has two problems, first, its price makes it innaccesible to many including me and second, it is in the box thinking. Sure, its got a touch sensitive pad but that is old technology repackaged. There are many hexagonal keyboards boards, some of which I believe are dropping in price (SOS showed one) and microtonal boards that I believe are far more innovative than the continuum.
I also think the "V Bow" looks very promising although again, so far outside the price range of most that it makes it all but unusable.