Sorry for the late answer, I moved from one place to a new one yesterday. Had only internet back today
. More place, but a lot of cardboard boxes to open and dispatch...
So...
@Mrnutty: best to post a new message, so I detect there is something new. better than update your own post. I'll update the history part with your new comment, with the date of the update.
@Everyone: I'm convinced Moog will do its utmost to have everyone happy with a functioning Sub 37. I'm sure the plastic shaft pot was choosen after thorough testing and prototyping. Maybe what was overlooked is the bigger off-axis lever/pressure the bigger knob applies to the shaft/pot ramp, having some of them to fail/fail quicker than intended. Some gentle user with good pot will never have the FFPP, some rough user with good pot will someday experience FFPP, some gentle user with bad pot will have FFPP sooner or later, some rough user with bad pot will have FFP quickly. The quality of a part often is a Gauss curve (a lot of components are ok for the job, some are bad, some are in fact extremely good, and NO ONE knows which one is the one you actually have). Parts are rated with figures such as numbers or rotations/actuations in the lifespan before failure. Look at the rotary encoders Teenage Engineering uses for their OP-1, these are MIL-spec. Great! Now look at the size, and the price! If you need MIL-spec for all the components of your Sub37, prepare yourself to pay much more than a Voyager.
My point is Moog designed an amazing mono synth, with capabilities very few if any other synth can pretend to have. And this, at a price which is not cheap, but surely not sky-high or unreachable (to call it cheap would be a tad too much from my point of view, but for the specs, it's actually a very good price tag)! A product is always a balance between costs and revenues, and one has to choose how to fit into a given cost. I don't say the SMD PP are cost cutting stuff/cheap stuff. They do the job, very well, normally. Now put a big knob on it, use it more than intended (Filter knob), choose a normal rated component, and maybe you'll have .5% of failure (not intended I mean).
Moog is too small to ruin its reputation on this. They have a name, a fanbase, they support their products and users a long time with updates/firmware/optional modifications; I'm sure given the situation, they won't ignore a user coming back with FFPP, even after warranty is out (my opinion here). We shouldn't be too worried about this, and I won't ask Moog or wait until they come and write here they will offer life support for FFPP (even if this would be amazing). Let's play with our Sub37, and the day it fails, if it fails, let's contact Moog.
In the end, everything fails, even us
.
All the best,
Greg