Hey! So, my mod wheel got bumped pretty hard, and wasn’t staying in place when I’d nudge it up for just a smidge of whatever- If not up all the way, it’d slowly fall back to zero-
SO, I opened it up and messed with the pot, and yep, now it doesn’t function- I’ve been getting by by just using the amount knob, but of course want to get my mod wheel back in action-
My question is, is the pot purchasable by itself? Or is there a decent alternate manufacturer out there that sells a pot with those specs?
thanks for ANY info!
Seth
I haven’t looked at it closely, but wouldn’t it just be a standard Alpha Pot? It should have the value on it. They can be ordered from virtually any supply house. I’m a fan of Jameco for stuff like that.
Yeah, it’s a regular Alpha pot, like all the others inside the Voyager. The only thing that I don’t know is its value and type (audio taper or linear).
Have an older set here, so newer Voyagers may use a different manufacturer. Uses a Bourns #3852A-282-103A for both pitch and mod. It’s a 10K cermet type linear.
Not sure what they use now, but that part comes up as obsolete, non-ROHS. Unknown what the new number or replacement part is. I’m on my third set of wheels, so they are not very robust. Actually had one seize up with little plastic shards falling out.
Next time I replace these, I’ll go with the old military spec Allen/Bradly type J pots. They last a lot longer and the ones in my Moog from 1969 still work great and won’t fall apart just because I use them. LOL!
Yeah, those Allen-Bradley were military grade ! I only had to open the one for the mod wheel on my Mini, to invert the carbon wiper that had become unevenly worn at a 45 degree angle. I expect it could be good for another 10 years or so…
BTW, Allen-Bradley was bought many years ago by Honeywell. But the company still makes the same kind of high grade sealed type pots. They’re pretty expensive though…
Same resistance value, and same type (audio taper or linear) as the one presently in your Old School, and one with the same length an diameter shaft.
Important note: As Kevin Lightner would probably point out, the Allen-Bradley Type-J do not go down to precisely 0 ohm at their minimum position. There will always be some residual resistance due to the carbon wiper used in the design. So, depending on how the modulation signal is passed thru this pot, you might end-up being unable to completely remove all the modulation with the mod wheel all the way down after having replaced the regular (presumably Alpha) pot in that circuit. On the Minimoog D, this has been a design flaw from the start, that was never corrected. There is always a very slight modulation bleeding with the mod wheel fully down. That’s because on the Mini, the full modulation is always present, and the mod wheel acts as an attenuator. Whereas in some other circuit designs, presumably the Voyager, it might be the opposite, the modulation might be increased by the mod wheel instead of shut down. And that might make the bleeding a little less noticeable.
Just tried to replace those cheapo bourns with some proper AB type J pots. Everything looked good as far as space, just enough room to fit. And the shaft and threaded sleeve were the same dimensions. But the extra wide diameter body on the type J is just a little too large for the L mounting bracket.
Too bad! The L bracket mounting hole could be enlarged a tiny bit, but it will effect the geometry of the wheel movement. Perhaps making the clearance of the wheel too close to the cutout. It does not miss by much, but the bracket needs to be altered to fit type J pots. I’m still going to go ahead and mod a set of wheels to the old Moog standard. Might even try Mini wheels, never did like those fat wheels and prefer a detent to a spring.
But I do have two sets of exploded LH controllers to experiment with. The way my Voyager is now is unacceptable. It is never in tune because the pitch wheel never gets to the same zero point. Can see it on a MIDI monitor, sometimes it stops at 32, sometimes at -17. My guess is this dates back to when to Voyager was introduced. The first units people complained there was a dead spot on the ptch wheel, making proper vibratos impossible. So they took away the dead spot. This is not that noticable if you always set the pitch wheel to a few semitones. But set to a fifth or an octave, it becomes an issue.
Oh well the part number is above for the replacement Bourns. The AB part I am using is JA1N056S103UA. When I find a non Bourns solution, I will post it. I’m sure there are other heavy duty pots that would work.
But if I remember right, my Voyager Old School had a slight dead zone on the pitch bend… I could be wrong, because I sold it a few years ago, (along with my EB model too) and don’t have any Voyager now…
BTW, Bourns do offer industrial grade conductive plastics type pots, that are probably a little smaller than those big A-B Type-J …
That could very well be. The Voyager I have here is a PE, so the pitch wheel is digitally scanned and noticable on the MIDI output. Could be the OS is a completly different circuit. Got my Voyager in 2005, and was a little pissed that they later offered the OS. Not a big fan of DCA’s. (Digital Controlled Anaolg).
Not an engineer, but there seems to be a lot of torsional load on the potentiometer, in that type of setup. Probably the reason the mod wheel pot broke. Even the L brackets are not as robust as they could be. When my Voyager arrived the wheels were not straight, but were easily bent back into position. There are smaller AB mod pots too. I would look for one with a sleeved bushing on the shaft. But you can see from the photos, those Bourns types they are using do not look like they can handle the repeated stress. Depends on how much you use the wheels too. The mileage on a set of wheels I use could be many times what another user might have, but I wore out two sets of those Bourns pots.
The OD on those type J pots was 1.090". A little buzz with a Dremel will enlogate the mounting hole enough to fit these in place, but I can not recommend anyone else to try this. Just that I can do it without any expense, I have all the spare parts here. But I am not going to try to replace them with the same set of pots that are known to fail me.
Wish I had a better solution for Filtered. But the type J pots won’t fit without altering.
I would also like to know if the mod pot is replaceable because on my Electric Blue when a function is modulated by the mod wheel it scratches just above 0 and its getting really annoying.
I started considering to get the after-touch mod for the sake of the mod and to get rid of the scratching caused by the faulty pot.
Depends on your skills. If you are able to solder and re-assemble the wheel mechanism, should be no problem. For a drop in solution, the upgraded aftertouch would be the way to go. Moog music seems to believe this is the solution, as the aftertouch upgrade is a simple circuitboard swap. But they only seem to offer the whole assembly that is a very expensive upgrade giving you a new complete assembly.
Those Bourns pots should be easy to source, 10K linear. Think I found them listed at around 10 bucks. They look like this:
I was able to upgrade to beefier AB type pots but ran into all kinds of clearance issues. So I would recommend replacing with the original Bourns type pots.
I had a different problem with my pitch wheel not returning to center. Especially noticable if I set the wheel to any interval a fifth or over. My pitch wheel would throw the Voyager and any MIDI connected synth out of tune. Bad, really bad! This issue I am finding has more to do with the return spring on the clear plexi wheel machanism. The plastic molded set has a different stop, and seems much better at returning to the same spot. Here are the two different wheels.
After doing some measurements, it was easy to see why the clear wheels did not always return to the same resistance. There is too much play in the return mechanism on those clear wheels. Even after replacing the pots with new ones, I still got readings that would not center with any repeated accuracy. While the molded wheels were spot on.
So I’m just going to use the molded ones. Always thought the lighted wheels were kind of cheesy anyway. But I was able to fit the AB type in the mechanism. Very tight fit with the clear wheels. Had to first alter the bracket and enlongate the mounting hole and drill a new locater hole so the new pot would not slide.
The clearance on the clear wheels was too tight with the lock washers on the screws that held a plate on top for the spring stops. So I had remove the lockwashers and it cleared. This is where the clear wheels and the molded one differ. The molded ones have the stops molded in, so no screws or lockwashers used on them. Plus there is a hard surface on the molded wheel. The clear wheel uses some kind of taped covering that wears out over time. Can see the screws touching the top with the lockwashers in place.
I was able to mount the AB’s in there but the clearance due to the width of the back of the pot limited any adjustments.
From the top you can see they just fit. The molded wheels are thinner and this is not an issue with them.
So in the end I found the problem I had was more to do with the clear wheels centering, then it was the actual pots being the reason. The new AB pots do feel more solid, and do not have as much side to side play as the Bourns do. But I don’t recommend it as a suitable replacment, especially with those clear wheels.
First of all thank you for the detailed explanation of the issue along with the pictures that you attached.
Do you have the Voyager After Pressure upgrade on yours? How much of an improvement is it compared to the old one do you know?
As of now I dont really use the after touch on my EB simply because it acts as a on/off control atm.
It surely is on my list of “to get” things but it is not a priority since im in the UK and dont think anyone stocks the parts over here.
This seems like the pot I need for the MOD wheel. They are less than £2 so no wonder the quality is crap. If I had the upgraded LH component I might go through the trouble of replacing the Bourns pots but since its the old type Im not going to bother.
Having said that I really need to replace the MOD pot as its affecting the wheel a lot in the lower range. This only becomes even more evident when the wheel CV is sent through the mult.
I have the aftertouch upgrade. Works great and it was just on/off before the upgrade. I did find it more usefull though by using the VX-351 and routing the CV via the attenuator, to adjust the ammount of aftertouch CV. For stuff like a bit of extra filter cutoff from aftertouch, it seem easier to dial in the ammount I wanted via the VX-351.
I did not order a Bourns replacement from Mouser, but the one you listed does not look like the correct one. The original part number comes up obsolete, #3852A-282-103A. Mouser has listed a #3852A-282-103AL? Not sure what the L is for, but here is a Mouser UK link to what looks to be the newer part. http://uk.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Bourns/3852A-282-103AL/?qs=sGAEpiMZZMtC25l1F4XBU4oRqbczCEe7Rzg8YwFcWEg%3d
A little more expensive at £7.23, but looks to be the proper replacement. Might want to ask Moog’s service if that is the correct part before ordering.
The aftertouch upgrade is a full set of wheels, so that would be another way to go.