Hi there, is it possible using the Moog One with Ableton Live10 with 3 tracks on 3 indipendent Midi channels?
I mean synth 1 refers to midi ch.1 (settings/midi i/o midi in/out channel), synth 2 to midi ch 2 and synth 3 to midi ch 3?
So that I can adress 3 different Channels to the 3 synths?
thank you for any advise and whow to do it.
regards
yes, it’s all in the manual.
Hi
I have read all about it in the manual. But:
even when selected Per synth for in and out and given the 3 synth different midi channels (e.g. 1,2,3) the incomming data is comming in all the 3 channels, even while keybord control is off for all the 3 synth.
What is wrong here?
Thank you for any advise
How is midi data coming in USB or DIN?
And what from?
Midi Data come from the mac directly and I created 3 channel strip in Ableton Live 10 given each track a different Midi channel input. But when playing the moog (e.g. Synth 1 on midi channel 1) all channel strips in Live get the data as well. The same if I play on synth 2 or 3, every time all channels gets data simoultaneously.
Any idea? thanks
I have the same issue in Live 11. Sending and receiving midi through usb.
I’ve also tried disconnecting the usb cable and using 2 midi cables, but nothing changed . I think that is a Moog One bug with Ableton Live. I will try in Logic Pro X to see if there is the same problem
I am really disappointed, this essential feature after such al long time of being in the world. Are we the first which are tring to use this feature? Lets see if it is the only issue with Live - I don’t think so. Have sent a request to moog some time ago but still waiting for an answer. Really strange !!! In such a essential matter of using the 3 Midi channels for the 3 different Synths. Lets see if it also happens with Logic. But I think it is a matter with the Moog itself.
I tried it out for you and I have a good message for all of us:
IT IS POSSIBLE.
I use Logic. I created three MIDI-Tracks with Channel 1-3.
On my Moog One in the settings I set the MIDI IN ROUTE to PER SYNTH
MIDI IN CHANNEL SYNTH1 : 1
MIDI IN CHANNEL SYNTH2: 2
MIDI IN CHANNEL SYNTH3: 3
MIDI IN PORTS: DIN
On my Prophet XL (used in this way as the master on CH 1) I can play / record / replay all different synths of the Moog One per channel.
I don‘t play much with MIDI, but I could not believe, that such an (for the most people) important
feature will not work on the Moog One. So, I connected my ESI M4U ex to my iMac, connected the Moog One over DIN to Port 7. In Logic, I used for each MIDI track the Port 7 with different channels (1,2,3).
Because I am not a MIDI Guru, it was easy done.
Maybe, at now I will work more with this feature … 
Really cool.
I have actually only short USB cables (Moog One is too far away to my iMAC), so I must try out the USB mode later.
It’s really strange even what “noisebit” wrote, because I checked with DIN connection and used MIDI Monitor to see what going on, and recognized that the moog one sends Midi data out on Channel 1,2 and 3 (while using LIVE 10) even when I have only Synth 1 used with a sound and the other Synths are emty!
The settings are the same (3 different midi channels for inand output/ Midi Rout PER SYNTH) but outgoing midi data is simoultaniouly on all the 3 midi channels.
And I am not the only one, “smv” had the same issue.
Is there anybody elsw who could confirm this?
Thank you - still haven’t got an answer from Moog 
Hi,
it is not strange what I wrote. I think, the different results depend on our different handling.
I use a Master-Keyboard. I don‘t use the Moog One Keyboard.- even thats what I wrote.
This works for me and is my personal handling.
Cheers
Hi,
#noisebit “nichts für ungut”, I used Logic for quit a long time, swapped to ableton because of some features I didn’t find in Logic and one of the differences is in Logic you create Midi Tracks, in Live you can too, but the case is here the same, and if you create in Live a strip “external instrument” for sendig the audio signal out to an external audio interface this case is here the same.
I just described the matter that with usb or midi the data view with “midi monitor” shows incomming midi data on all of the 3 midi channels simmoultaneolsy, even if I activated only synth 1 (e.g.) - but never the less, I am not the only LIVE user with that case, I hope Moog will show mercy to answer my request 
regards
It doesn’t matter if any of the synths are empty or not. If keyboard control is on for all three synths, you will be sending MIDI on three channels at once.
Try turning on keyboard control for only one synth.
Yes, thank you for the advise, I’ve already choosen it in my setup.
Here I can show you, the the MIDI Monitor displayes that the moog send out the same data on all the 3 different midi channels imoultiously without activating the keyboard contols ‘on’.
This is even without preloading any DAW only the midi monitor is on.
Any explenations?
just to make sure we are talking about the same thing…
turn off keyboard control for all synths, to verify that your ONE doesn’t send any MIDI notes.
PANEL FOCUS > SYNTH 1
KEYBOARD CONTROL > ON to OFF
PANEL FOCUS > SYNTH 2
KEYBOARD CONTROL > ON to OFF
PANEL FOCUS > SYNTH 3
KEYBOARD CONTROL > ON to OFF
now, turn on keyboard control for only one synth.
PANEL FOCUS > SYNTH 1
KEYBOARD CONTROL > ON to ON
I installed Logic 10.5 on my MBP to show that this obviously not a singular matter of Ableton Live.
As you can see on the Panel Focus all Synths are turned OFF.
Whether a midi channel in Logic is aktive ore not (you see it in the two attachements), if I hit a key the are midi Note on and Note off messages seen in the MidiMonitor Window on the Logic surface.
And as you can see in the 3rd Attachement the Midi i/o settings are perfect.
Any idea why the Moog obviously behave like that?
Change to the following in the Settings.
MIDI I/O > MIDI OUT ROUTE > ALL SYNTHS
this should solve your problem.
You will still be able to trigger individual synths through their respective MIDI channels.
Sorry I have to disappoint you, the settings you suggested send midi only on channel 1, never the less which synth I have turned on.
For me was important to find a setup which definitly sends only midi on which that was predefined.
I think moog suggests it when using Midi rout in/out Per synth for different channels. Thats what it seems to mean.
BUT: It doesn’t work that way.
As you can see in the pics above (the white displayed window in the Logic part - it’s the midi monitor window), when using this configuration the moog sends - even if any synth is turned “on” in the keybord control part- midi Note on/off messeges out on all the predifined channels.
For it seems that I am the only one who tries to figgure out the issue and to be able to use 3 synth independly.
I think I don’t have to be a midi guru - even though I have some experience with that - and it isn’t really tricky to set the settings as desribed above and to create 3 midi tracks in the DAW but with or without any DAW the Midi Monito shows, without having activating any synths this issue of incomming and outgoing Data on all the chosen channels.
Perhaps someone knows more about it?
thak you for your time
regards
Addendum : important !
it works as I just have to mention !
But only - what ‘noisebit’ wrote on the first inex page - if I use a external Master keyboard !
In that case the are the 3 different channels give out 
but if I play the moog itself, all 3 channels are simoultaneosly working.
By the way - for the case that you work on it on an external keyboard and choose for Synth 1 Main L/R (in the output section) and for synth 2 SUB L/R you can hear an play things on to different outputs.
But Synth 3 could only use Main L/R or SUB L/R, so here you would have to sounds together on one output.
Here is my question, when moog create 3 synths, why doesn’t createted 3 independent outputs for all of them?
Has anybody an idea?
thanks
I’m afraid you misunderstand the MIDI workflow with a DAW. You are not supposed to trigger your synths directly from the keyboard. You will end up with doubled notes – the same note will be triggered by your keyboard and by your DAW. I suggest that you google “MIDI and ‘Local Off’”.